Most Useful Social Networks for Marketers

social media conceptMarketers are spending, on average, six or more hours per week on social media. Facebook and LinkedIn are cited as the most important social networks, depending on whether you are a B to C or a B to B company.  Twitter is a distant third for both segments of companies and both mention blogging as being important to them.

Marketing Nugget bottomline for Marketers:  Invest in social media. If you are focusing on B to C, invest more marketing efforts into Facebook. If you are a B to B company, invest more marketing efforts into LinkedIn and blogging.LearnMore-Blue-Primary-16




Marketing in a World of Digital Sharing



Are you drowning in social media noise and chaos?

Authored by Sujata Ramnarayan, Ph.D.

Like most marketers, you are drowning in social media noise and chaos.   Businesses have simply jumped in without tying social media outcomes to any business objectives.
The purpose of this book is to help you:
- See how social media fits into your overall marketing strategy
- Understand how best to develop social media with allocation among different tools
- Figure out the extent to which social media is relevant to your business or department, and how best to implement it given an increasingly digital world of sharing and an empowered customer voice

Publishers Weekly says “Ramnarayan provides a detailed, contemporary primer that illuminates the promise and peril of the brave new world of social media. Ramnarayan herself acknowledges that social media is no panacea—her crisp presentation, with chapter summaries to highlight the main pointers, confirms that companies that choose not to listen to customers stand to lose ground to competitors who do.”


“Sujata Ramnarayan’s excellent book does several things that I have not seen in other treatments of this subject. She takes a reasoned perspective on a topic that is often full of hyperbole. The book is filled with advice for the marketer that is both practical and strategic. It helps the marketer to leverage social media where it can best impact business performance. I highly recommend the book.”
- Gordon Wyner, Editor-In-Chief, Marketing Management

“This practical guide to social media marketing cuts through the noise with clear advice on how to turn strategy into practice. With the help of effective charts and analysis, the reader can gain real insight into social media’s influence in corporate marketing. By showing how building quality content in social media is no longer an option for corporations, this is also a lesson in building a brand by listening to your customers. ”
-Rajesh Subramaniam, SVP, Global Marketing and Customer Experience, FedEx Services

Are you Listening? – What Customers are Saying about Target

The data breach at Target Corp. affects 110 million customers in the United States which is equivalent to almost every single household in the United States possibly being affected. It has led to many articles being published, commented on, and many tweeting on the breach. An analysis of social data on Twitter and social commentary on a New York Times article reveals sentiments expressed by customers.

The news on the number of customers affected by the data breach at Target came out in installments – 40 million, 70 million, and then 110 million. Earlier in December, the company admitted a breach into its systems that resulted in stolen credit card information on customers that had shopped at its stores in the United States from November 27th to mid-December. Later, it admitted to a larger breach that had been going on over a longer time-frame.

 Figure 1: Analysis of Tweets on Target Data Breach

Analysis of Tweets on Target Data Breach

Analysis of Tweets on Target Data Breach

Customers to Target: Stop Calling us “Guests”!

An analysis of data from Tweets (see Figure 1 above based on social data analysis) and a separate analysis of comments generated by an article in the New York Times reveals a lot about what customers are thinking that the retail industry should be paying attention to. While the data from tweets reflect immediate reaction, they reflect shock at the enormity of the breach. Customers are unhappy that the information came out in installments and kept growing. Further analysis of data from over 1500 tweets over a 30 minute time period showed four segments of consumers. There were those who were shocked at the fact that the number had reached 110 million as revealed by the following tweet:

“@Target First 40 million, then 70 million, now 110 million?? Is it safe to say we’ll be at 200 million by next week? #JustBeHonest”

While Target might have released the data slowly to lessen the impact of disclosure on holiday sales, many questioned why it came out in installments and how much more was yet to come. It actually resulted in more tweets being generated on the new breach. The tweets on news of further breach accounted for a second segment.

A third segment focused on talking about the cost to Target because of lawsuits and impending probes. As one tweet mentioned even more than an impact on sales long-term, the costs add up due to other steps to be taken up in cleaning up the mess. Target itself admitted to seeing a lower percentage of sales at its stores after the disclosure.

There was a fourth and largest segment to which it was business as usual at Target, with mild remarks on the breach. Here is a sample of tweets reflecting this sentiment:

 ”How do me and my mom manage to spend 300$ at target ….

“My mom went all the way to Target for some freaking popcorn?

“Can u shop safely at Target anymore?”

so there was this bag that target had and i had wanted it since forever and now i have it and i am in love”

In general, the tweets reflect concern for security when shopping at all retailers than specifically about the Target brand.

Comments on a New York Times article, however, revealed unhappiness over the way Target handled this entire disclosure process (See Figure 2 below).

Figure 2: Analysis of Social Commentary on Target Data Breach

Analysis of Social Commentary on Target Data Breach

Analysis of Social Commentary on Target Data Breach

The fact that the numbers affected ballooned over time brought forth concern regarding leadership and concern about security. Many suggested that customers use cash instead. The conversation also revolved around how Target should stop using the word “Guest” when its does not treat them as such. If there is one sentence to describe the reaction of these customers, it is as follows:

“The arrogance of Target astounds;

Stop calling us your Guests.”


The impact of the breach is already clear. While the damage is done, it has made it important to usher in newer chip based credit card technology. This has also resulted in arguments between retail and financial institutions on who should bear the cost and burden of new technologies. The cost of such a breach is not just in identity theft at the individual level but a rise in black market for fraudulent credit cards that has impact on banks, law enforcement agencies, and retailers.

Next Steps

It is clear from the analysis that Target did not handle the disclosure process very well. The fact that the disclosure came out in installments, while increasing in its revealed damage – both in numbers and extent – only made it worse. The analysis reveals that Target customers hate being referred to as “Guests” and then treated in a way that is devoid of any protection and smacks of a lack of authenticity on its part to its customers. This breach is sure to make some customers weary in the short term of shopping at Target. However, this is a much bigger issue of protecting customer information with appropriate technology at all retailers so as to avoid larger costs resulting from an aftermath of such crisis. Some customers did suggest using only cash, while admitting that they never have enough on hand. While this might be a wish, it is likely to stay a wish for consumers in today’s economy. At least in the short term though, some customers are using cash only as stated here. As some of the tweets revealed, the larger impact is likely to come from other sources such as monitoring and probes.

Target is well-advised to take some steps to make its customers feel safer about shopping. It is clear that its customers dislike the use of the term “Guests” to address them. The ritual of calling its customers “Guests,” is perceived as just that – a ritual. It does not reflect a culture of caring. While its customers appreciate many products at its stores, the relatively higher quality compared to Walmart, and the fact that it is better stocked than Walmart, the company could do more to build its brand health. Starting with taking steps to make customers feel secure about doing transactions at its store and taking the lead among retail could be one such step. Target Corp. Chief Executive Gregg Steinhafel’s call to banks and other retailers to adopt chip based card technology is a step in the right direction. This is an opportunity for Target to lead the way for other retailers.



Which Half of Your Google Search Advertising is Being Wasted?

Which half is being wasted – branded vs non-branded keywords

We all know the 19th century adage “I know half the money I spend on advertising is wasted; I just don’t know which half.” Online click trackable advertising promised to change that. It seems it has. It turns out that “branded keyword” advertising is not effective for well-known companies. Companies with known brand names would do well to re-allocate the money they are spending on search engine marketing to other areas. In a recent HBR blog, Professor Fisman referred to a preliminary study by eBay that calls into question the effectiveness of Google advertising for big well-known brand names. In an elaborate and controlled experiment conducted by eBay, its researchers found that when Google (or Yahoo! or Bing) search advertising was discontinued for a sample of its potential audience, traffic to the site continued to perform as well as it did in areas in which Google “brand keyword” (defined as any keyword that is simply the company or product name or includes the name of the company such as “eBay shoes”) advertising was still being used. This study underlines

Read more »

Book Giveaway For Marketing in a World of Digital Sharing: Are you drowning in social media noise and chaos?

Marketing in a World of Digital Sharing

by Sujata Ramnarayan

Giveaway ends March 31, 2013.

See the giveaway details
at Goodreads.


Why marketers need to lead with data and insight

Marketing tech dataGartner Group predicts that by 2016, 80% of marketing technology spending will come out of the marketing departments. What are marketers spending on? It falls in three areas:

Read more »

Are you passing the Customer Qualification Process?

Businesses continue to think of the funnel as a sales funnel with leads entering and being qualified, and hopefully reaching the end-point of becoming a customer. A recent study shows that this process is changing. Companies need to change their perspective because it is the potential customers that are qualifying suppliers. So, are you in the “Customer’s Buyer Funnel?”

Read more »

Pay $7 for a cup of coffee? – Very Likely!!!

Starbucks is going super-premium. The company that got people to pay $4 for a product they had paid less than a dollar for is adopting a new long-term strategy. It has introduced a $7 cup of coffee in 50 of its Northwest stores made from a hard to grow coffee bean -the Costa Rica Finca Palmilara. It plans to roll out this product nationally next year. Starbucks might be on to something here again!

Read more »

How to Use Gamification to Build Digital Loyalty

Using  Gamification to Build Digital Loyalty

ENGAGE2012 is a conference hosted by Badgeville, the company that provides a solution for behavior gaming. It was a great conference with some interesting perspectives. Most CEOs today acknowledge the importance of social in their overall strategy even as the world seems to be taken over by social fatigue. Badgeville’s conference hinged on the next step of increasing social engagement. As Chris Lynch, Director of Product Marketing at Badgeville said – the intersection of social plus gamification is a powerful combination.

 What is Gamification

In case you are new to the concept of gamification, it refers to a set of specific feedback based processes designed to encourage specific behaviors.

Read more »

Why Social Media is NOT free

Social media has become popular as a communication channel for companies partly because of its low barriers to entry, along with its popularity among target customers.  Social media channels are free to enter, but associated costs and problems become apparent later. That is also one of the reasons why the return on investment is hard to measure. To download the article, please login.

Read more »